Welcome to Gaia! ::

Why Not?

Back to Guilds

No rules, just Fun! Join today. 

Tags: Roleplaying, Polls, Spam 

Reply "IDT" Intelligent Discussion Threads!
2 driving forces Sciences And Religions what do you think ? Goto Page: 1 2 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

poll
  .........
View Results

Skyliner778

Dapper Noob

10,250 Points
  • Noob wrangler 100
  • Nudist Colony 200
  • Forum Regular 100
PostPosted: Fri Aug 03, 2007 4:12 pm


the two driving forces in the world are Science and religion they both are best kept apart but i find a deep problem in that who's to say that god didn't start "evolution" because i'm very compelled to not believe that through random processes that life can be created in a mass amount of chemicals because look at Venus they have no life and the Gas giants don't AS FAR AS WE KNOW OF . now you see that i believe that their is a god in fact i'm a Christian and very rooted in science with my mind it is one of the subjects i excel in and through both i believe the two are deeply intertwined but that's just me what do you all think
PostPosted: Fri Aug 03, 2007 10:07 pm


I'm athiest. I believe that religion and science are utterly separate, and should never be mixed. But that's just my personal opinion. Not going to go putting anybody down or assaulting them for their beliefs, as long as nobody does the same for me.

I believe utterly in the big bang, evolution, and all that. It just makes the most sense to me. If God created everything, who or what created God? No matter what, there has to be some spontaneous upshoot of life.

Deppfan


Calypsophia

PostPosted: Sat Aug 04, 2007 8:40 am


I never thought the concepts of 'god' and 'evolution' were mutually exclusive. tho I reject the idea of personal deities, I do believe in a source and nature to me is divine. it is clear to me that this planet is regulated, and I also cannot view the existence of life and the delicately balanced cycles of nature, complete with it's own laws, as some random roll of the dice chance, accident, or mere coincidence.
PostPosted: Mon Aug 06, 2007 4:53 pm


lilraine
I never thought the concepts of 'god' and 'evolution' were mutually exclusive. tho I reject the idea of personal deities, I do believe in a source and nature to me is divine. it is clear to me that this planet is regulated, and I also cannot view the existence of life and the delicately balanced cycles of nature, complete with it's own laws, as some random roll of the dice chance, accident, or mere coincidence.


Well, it's not really chance or accident. Through random mutation, new attributes surface, providing new traits. If they are helpful, the lifeform lives on to reproduce, and spreads this adaptation. Eventually, all of them have this adaptation, because those without it were not able to survive; they died out. This is what causes all the change in the world.

Deppfan


Cornelius loh Quatious

PostPosted: Tue Aug 07, 2007 3:20 pm


The reason people tend to exclude religion from science and science from religion is because of vast misconceptions and poor logic from both sides. They can coexist quite peacefully and I know several people who are living proof of it (not being especially religious myself, I'm not one of them. Personally, I prefer to keep an open mind.).

Science explains the "how" in the physical world, the mechanisms and methods by which we can predict and reasonably explain phenomena that occur in the physical world.

Religion provides a set of moral guidelines pertaining to the metaphysical world, one which cannot be proven or disproven at this point, and therefore must be taken with faith. It provides explainations for the "why" we must act certain ways and provides comfort that there is a grander scale than we are seeing. At least, this is generally what religion is SUPPOSED to do; as we've seen, many tend to take this a step further and use it to justify their own political agendas. There are also those who take religious stories and interpret them quite literally, despite their status as myth and legend. What these people do is focus far too much on the WORDS and not enough on the MESSAGE.
PostPosted: Tue Aug 07, 2007 3:44 pm


deppfan
lilraine
I never thought the concepts of 'god' and 'evolution' were mutually exclusive. tho I reject the idea of personal deities, I do believe in a source and nature to me is divine. it is clear to me that this planet is regulated, and I also cannot view the existence of life and the delicately balanced cycles of nature, complete with it's own laws, as some random roll of the dice chance, accident, or mere coincidence.


Well, it's not really chance or accident. Through random mutation, new attributes surface, providing new traits. If they are helpful, the lifeform lives on to reproduce, and spreads this adaptation. Eventually, all of them have this adaptation, because those without it were not able to survive; they died out. This is what causes all the change in the world.


yes, well "random mutation" to me = chance. because not all species work out as they are and die out naturally rather than furthering their evolution, it is a chance. a roll of the dice, so to speak. what I'm saying tho, is evolution and deity are not mutually exclusive in that one doesnt cancel out the other. SOMEthing got the ball rolling to begin with. and if you say it was the big bang, then SOMEthing happened to cause that... not saying it's some conscious omnipotent being (I dont believe in those) but some source to it all.

Calypsophia


Deppfan

PostPosted: Tue Aug 07, 2007 7:00 pm


lilraine
deppfan
lilraine
I never thought the concepts of 'god' and 'evolution' were mutually exclusive. tho I reject the idea of personal deities, I do believe in a source and nature to me is divine. it is clear to me that this planet is regulated, and I also cannot view the existence of life and the delicately balanced cycles of nature, complete with it's own laws, as some random roll of the dice chance, accident, or mere coincidence.


Well, it's not really chance or accident. Through random mutation, new attributes surface, providing new traits. If they are helpful, the lifeform lives on to reproduce, and spreads this adaptation. Eventually, all of them have this adaptation, because those without it were not able to survive; they died out. This is what causes all the change in the world.


yes, well "random mutation" to me = chance. because not all species work out as they are and die out naturally rather than furthering their evolution, it is a chance. a roll of the dice, so to speak. what I'm saying tho, is evolution and deity are not mutually exclusive in that one doesnt cancel out the other. SOMEthing got the ball rolling to begin with. and if you say it was the big bang, then SOMEthing happened to cause that... not saying it's some conscious omnipotent being (I dont believe in those) but some source to it all.


I get what you're saying, but calling it "chance" makes it sound trivial in a way, like an insult or something. I guess it's the same way very religious people feel when their beliefs are scrutinized. (Not saying you're scrutinizing me or my beliefs.)

And yes, something did start it all, but I do not assume, nor will I ever assume to know exactly what happened. Nobody will ever truly know for sure. That's why a lot of people turn to faith. At least there, there's an explaination for how everything happened. It might not all be true, but at least it's something to get people through the day. Religion and faith are coping mechanisms, in my opinion (not my original idea... check out the book The God Part of the Brain.)

Humans began to realize that they were mortal and came up with a means and a ways for it all... a reason for existance, so that life would not seem so pointless and scary. Unfortunately, it became scary with all the warnings and cautionary stories in the bible and other holy books. And then there is all the abuse of power. But that's another story alltogether.

There are days when I feel that things would be simpler if there was some all-seeing, all-knowing supreme being that had a plan for everything and made sure things didn't go spiraling down the drain. But it just doesn't make sense or work for me personally. Maybe that part of the brain that controls all the religious aspects is dormant in me and most of my family. Or maybe we just know better.
PostPosted: Wed Aug 08, 2007 5:07 am


deppfan
lilraine
deppfan
lilraine
I never thought the concepts of 'god' and 'evolution' were mutually exclusive. tho I reject the idea of personal deities, I do believe in a source and nature to me is divine. it is clear to me that this planet is regulated, and I also cannot view the existence of life and the delicately balanced cycles of nature, complete with it's own laws, as some random roll of the dice chance, accident, or mere coincidence.


Well, it's not really chance or accident. Through random mutation, new attributes surface, providing new traits. If they are helpful, the lifeform lives on to reproduce, and spreads this adaptation. Eventually, all of them have this adaptation, because those without it were not able to survive; they died out. This is what causes all the change in the world.


yes, well "random mutation" to me = chance. because not all species work out as they are and die out naturally rather than furthering their evolution, it is a chance. a roll of the dice, so to speak. what I'm saying tho, is evolution and deity are not mutually exclusive in that one doesnt cancel out the other. SOMEthing got the ball rolling to begin with. and if you say it was the big bang, then SOMEthing happened to cause that... not saying it's some conscious omnipotent being (I dont believe in those) but some source to it all.


I get what you're saying, but calling it "chance" makes it sound trivial in a way, like an insult or something. I guess it's the same way very religious people feel when their beliefs are scrutinized. (Not saying you're scrutinizing me or my beliefs.)

And yes, something did start it all, but I do not assume, nor will I ever assume to know exactly what happened. Nobody will ever truly know for sure. That's why a lot of people turn to faith. At least there, there's an explaination for how everything happened. It might not all be true, but at least it's something to get people through the day. Religion and faith are coping mechanisms, in my opinion (not my original idea... check out the book The God Part of the Brain.)

Humans began to realize that they were mortal and came up with a means and a ways for it all... a reason for existance, so that life would not seem so pointless and scary. Unfortunately, it became scary with all the warnings and cautionary stories in the bible and other holy books. And then there is all the abuse of power. But that's another story alltogether.

There are days when I feel that things would be simpler if there was some all-seeing, all-knowing supreme being that had a plan for everything and made sure things didn't go spiraling down the drain. But it just doesn't make sense or work for me personally. Maybe that part of the brain that controls all the religious aspects is dormant in me and most of my family. Or maybe we just know better.


Indeed, I agree with you. man created the gods in his image and likeness in order to try and understand life and the world he lives in. that is why I dont believe in personal gods. we tend to give whatever this 'source' is, a costume based on what we think it should look like, or be, we give it it's characteristics based on the human perspective, which is the ONLY perspective we have, so it's only natural. but that doesnt mean it's correct.

Calypsophia


Verderbnis

PostPosted: Thu Aug 09, 2007 4:22 am


Religion is only a way to answer questions which are not yet scientifically answered.

Thousand years ago, people thought a god is upset if a volcano erupted or a Tsunami hit them. Today, members of Voodoo think of a curse if they get ill, but they could never imagine to run to a doctor and get medications, they are running to a shaman instead.

There is no higher will, except evolutions or natures will. For example the earth has only life, because some matter thought it'd be cool to catalyze to DNA, mutating to single cells.

Also I don't believe into aliens visiting the earth, what interest should higher evolved lifeforms have to visit us? If they search for another intelligent race, they should visit the star system next door.
PostPosted: Thu Aug 09, 2007 3:15 pm


heh.. concerning your comment mentioning 'natures will'.. to many nature itself is god. but people personified it by calling it 'mother nature' (one of the costumes I mentioned earlier). I see the divine in nature, so I'd be inclined to agree, tho it is genderless.

Calypsophia


angelkiss98

PostPosted: Sat Aug 11, 2007 1:49 pm


was reading this and remembered I read something about evolution begining to look like it went a different way. So I'm posting the link for you guys so you can take a look.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20070809/ap_on_sc/human_evolution;_ylt=AnsmLqcMX0gahwDseNlRRs8PLBIF
PostPosted: Sat Aug 11, 2007 2:33 pm


I too, have heard of this.

Calypsophia


angelkiss98

PostPosted: Sat Aug 11, 2007 3:40 pm


I just thought t might help people understand some things better or make it a little more interesting. /shrug. I just believe in the earth more than anything else so i didn't want to get too into the conversation just thought it would be interesting for you guys biggrin
PostPosted: Sat Aug 11, 2007 4:04 pm


I've thought and thought about the most appropriate label for me. I have both atheistic and pagan leanings. the 2 seem mutually exclusive when looking at it on the surface, but they dont have to be. it all depends on what your concept of god is.

but back to the topic at hand... it was on a show on tv I think, that I saw where there were actually a few human-like or related species that evolved at different periods. we evolved from one particular type of beastie that used to live in trees and started walking upright once living in trees was no longer possible. some species lived right along side the ones that evolved into what we are today, and some that began or could have began the evolutionary process towards 'humanity' died off at various other periods in time.

Calypsophia


squarecircle

PostPosted: Wed Aug 15, 2007 12:23 pm


dboyzero
The reason people tend to exclude religion from science and science from religion is because of vast misconceptions and poor logic from both sides.


"Both sides"? You're kidding me, right? Science and religion aren't mutually exclusive-- they're not even related. They're in totally different playing fields.

You do realize that most SCIENTISTS in the US are Christian, right? How are scientists suffering from "vast misconceptions and poor logic" when they're religious for the most part?

No, NO. The ONLY misconceptions come from the fundamentalists. Everyone else with any common sense knows that it's silly to think there's a dispute between religion and science. That's like saying there's a dispute between my computer and your underwear.
Reply
"IDT" Intelligent Discussion Threads!

Goto Page: 1 2 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum