Please be truthful

[Atili Nanna]

Some people say my art is good, other say its bad. Can you tell me what you think?
[x][y][z]  

[spearquest]

x is not bad for a body style but i can't base your work without seeing the head.
y is pointless to me. i didn't see anything but words and a very faint hand.
z is ok. it's a good starting point.  

[Zlump]

i like x surprised  

[Aranka Taine]

X is good, I'd say. Y didn't seem to be much of art, but a poem of some kind. Z needs work, but I agree with what was already said, it's a good starting point. I can see you improving from there.  

[Arachnakid]

I couldn't access Y for some reason. The other two seem pretty much average; people who don't draw will say that it's good, but it needs a lot of work. I don't mean to be mean; this is about where I was when I first started seriously drawing. You should definitely avoid anime/manga style drawing until you have a firm understanding of realistic drawing. It may seem "cool", but you won't really do well in it without techniques learned from still life. Practice is tedious, it's work, but it's necessary for quality artwork.  

[Kitsune Voss]

the first isnt horrible but it's a bit out of porportion
the second i have no opinion on
the 3rd needs a lot of work

work on drawing things realistically and work on it a lot before you move to cartooning because even in anime style drawing proportions matter. This is the kind of art that people who dont draw much think is great but for people who do it's below their usual standards. don't be discouraged but do practice  

[Hioni-Neko]

I agree with the two above.  

[U FaiLz]

x was good
z was , well it wask o.k. could use some work

however, y was great and sad. i could see it was full of passion and emotion, however depression is not the best emotion to be expressing =(  

[winter rat]

X: It's pretty good, I'd say. Just do a little more work and it will improve.
Y: That's just a poem.
Z: Didn't really like it.